- The complaint includes musical charts that aim to demonstrate parallels between the songs’ chord progressions, melodies and rhythms. The songwriters include their own 2009 version, as well as the Cardle version as examples. Their lawyer, Richard Busch – who won a similar suit regarding Robin Thicke’s “Blurred Lines” for the family of Marvin Gaye last year – claims that some 70 percent of the chorus to “Photograph” is identical to that of “Amazing,” right down to the phrasing.
I must have listened to the other 30 percent in my comparison because though similar, I go along with what I heard one guy say once, basically that there are only eight notes, and you can only put them together in so many ways.